A Disappointing Purchase

A Disappointing Purchase

It’s been a while since I posted anything. I do have several partly written, but I just haven’t had the motivation to finish them. So I thought I’d just put up a quick one today.

I bought this aluminum plate with a thin layer of green resin on the surface, which was claimed to contain “12000 grit diamond,” from AliExpress. I did some testing with it on my S110V Spyderco Para Military 2 and was surprised and disappointed to find that the hone wasn’t cutting the vanadium carbides in the way I would expect.

To investigate, I sawed off a small piece of the hone for analysis. A cross section through the resin layer shows that there is plenty of abrasive, although they are too large to call “12k grit.” Also, these are some very unusual shapes for diamond particles…

SEM image of the resin cross sectioned and polished by focused ion beam.

Next, I did elemental mapping on that surface, to see what the various materials are.

Elemental maps of the resin cross section.

There are three distinct materials in the cross section. The sharp-edge particles are revealed to be silicon carbide. The dark region between them shows carbon and oxygen, as expected for polymer resin. The small, bright particles are chromium oxide, explaining the green colour of the resin. I don’t see any diamonds.

,

18 responses to “A Disappointing Purchase”

      • there shld be some lettering on one of the sides

        I have an extra piece and will ship to you a piece that I bought from DMD direct. do give yr address

        Like

        • I think you mean like this:

          As with all of my posts, there are more images and analysis than I discuss, as I am cautious to confirm the results I present. In fact, I purchased 3 DMD diamond resin hones from two different AliExpress stores nearly a year apart. All three are composed of silicon carbide with little or no diamond.

          Like

  1. I’d act surprised, but… Well, you know…

    Sorry that happened to you Todd. I hope it was cheap at least. Too bad you can’t return it at high velocity through their car window. =)

    –Eric

    Like

  2. Hoping it was isolated incident or counterfeit prod. A real bummer in any case. Sorry u got burned. Many thanks for the heads up Todd.

    Like

  3. As consumers I believe we are being lied to on many fronts.
    If a product states that it’s a diamond sharpener, I believe it is expected
    That the majority of the product (excepting the base which it is applied to)
    Is Diamond, not glue or a b c d e.

    Like

  4. Thanks for sharing, much appreciated.
    There is a lot of information about a lot of things ‘out there’.
    Finding good information is like finding 12000 grit diamond in a Chinese stone claiming it.
    Thanks again

    Like

    • Not that I can think of, other than perhaps the performance on high vanadium carbide steel.

      Interesting, I hadn’t noticed that the body text had switched to dark grey from black. I made the mistake of subscribing to wordpress.com for 3 years, so I am stuck with their awful editor for a bit longer.

      Like

Leave a Reply to Eric Sprehe Cancel reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

%d bloggers like this: